Date: Tue, 17 Feb 2004 11:52:36
From: "Al Smith"> It has been a very inconsistent character
> development for T'Pol. And besides, even your mediocre Trek-fan
> knows that Vulcans kiss with their fingers.
Hmmmm, I wonder if that's all they do with their fingers?
Date: Tue, 17 Feb 2004 17:55:18
From: "Ron/Ronniemac" <ronniemac@w...>> Then there is the subplot that puts this entire episode in the
> toilet, too which the standards for Star Trek drama have now sunk
> to an all time low.
Yep. The above and the rest of your observations I have been pretty
much
what have been saying all week. It did more damage to Enterprise,
truly
being a Star Trek show then all the afore mentioned things that have
happened, put together.
You are also right, when you say they did a bad job on a really
theme. I tip
my hat to the way you put it together.
Date: Wed, 18 Feb 2004 09:00:37
From: "Manky Badger" <mb@freeserve.co.uk>> Overall, not bad, but not
> great either.
>
This sums up all of Enterprise, doesn't it ?
I've been re-watching TNG season 3 and there's some outstanding episodes
there. There's not one Enterprise that is really sticking in my mind at
the
moment.
> Then there is the subplot that puts this entire episode in the
> toilet, too which the standards for Star Trek drama have now sunk
> to an all time low. T'Pol and Trip have sex. And not much drama to
> speak of either. Whose dumb-ass idea was this anyway? The whole
> build up of the final sex scene was very dry and lame. At least
> there could have been a semi-legitimate love scene to go along
> with this. All the viewer got to see was adolescent sex acting (at
> best). It was a very poor attempt at "sexing-up" the show. That's
> what daytime soap operas are for.
Exactly !!
Date: Wed, 18 Feb 2004 09:07:37
From: "Polido7" <polido7@aol.com>> Then there is the subplot that puts this entire episode in the
> toilet, too which the standards for Star Trek drama have now sunk
> to an all time low. T'Pol and Trip have sex. And not much drama to
> speak of either. Whose dumb-ass idea was this anyway? The whole
> build up of the final sex scene was very dry and lame. At least
> there could have been a semi-legitimate love scene to go along
> with this. All the viewer got to see was adolescent sex acting (at
> best). It was a very poor attempt at "sexing-up" the show. That's
> what daytime soap operas are for.
Yes. I agree. I though it broke character for T'Pol, too. The only
way that
would have made sense, would be if this had been a pon-farr episode.
But they
already did a pon-farr episode, didn't they?