Robert Reed
Above:  39 years of fun behind a wrench and an oil leak. Hit the image for a bio.

Stated intent of this page

HOW DOES YOUR COMPANY DEAL WITH EXPENSIVE MISTAKES MADE BY YOUR TECHNICIANS?
boeing
Boeing Commercial Airplanes took a huge forward leap in this area.  More later.

PUSHING THE ENVELOPE TOWARD PERFECTION
It was in March, 1979. My supervisor gave me the terrifying news. A family of four was killed in an airplane I had just put back together the day before.  It's every aircraft technician's nightmare, and it happened to me.

pa28
Piper Cherokee 180 of the type I performed a 100 hour inspection and
oil change on prior to the family perishing in it the next day

I walked through the hangar door.  My supervisor found me and said "Bob, you know that plane you inspected and serviced Saturday?"

"Yea", I said with an instantaneous sinking feeling in my stomach.

He continued, "A guy, his wife and two small children were killed in it after leaving here on Sunday".

I was speechless.  He studied my reaction.  I didn't even know what to think, let alone what to do.  I remembered making a big mistake during the job, but I didn't think it had damaged the aircraft's engine.  It was all I could think about for the next few days.  Any small mistake can result in expensive machinery breaking or people being killed.  Nothing less than perfection can be allowed.  What in the world was I thinking when I chose this profession?

Any technician hearing the news that his repair went bad knows the feeling.  It doesn't matter if it is like this case, or if it's a Cummins QSB in a hay bailing machine.  You might as well swing a baseball bat at my rib cage.  Just run that sword right through me. 

People who are not professional technicians probably don't fully understand the effect news of this type can have on a tech, even if it wasn't a quadruple fatal aviation accident.  An engine failing in a commercial fishing vessel right after a tech was into it is no different than a tech sending an airplane spiralling down and ending up as a smoking hole in the ground. 

Commercial fishing boats in the Pacific Northwest go out in dangerous seas, and if the engine fails at the wrong time, like in the mouth of the harbor entrance with 10 to 12 foot breaking swells nearby, there's a good chance that some of the crew will either die in the water or be killed as they are getting slammed into a rock jetty. 

 A bad result is the complete antithesis of what your purpose in life is
.

On that quadruple fatal aircraft accident I did something wrong during the service visit.  It haunted me for days.  A whole family perished probably because of my mistake.  Unimaginable. 

Our hangar was next door to the district F.A.A. office.  I expected a visit from them.  They have law enforcement powers.  They could arrest me.  My supervisor told me they would be over to talk to me.  More on this one later.

fatal crash
No technician wants this to happen on the machine's first trip out from his disassembly and reassembly.
It happened to me in 1979.  This is a nightmare scenario.


THE PROFESSIONAL TECHNICIAN'S IMPERATIVE
When it comes to the world of mistakes, professional technicians come closest to mistake free job performance for obvious reasons.  No other option exists.  The consequences of forgetting just one task in a complex assembly procedure involving hundreds of separate parts are beyond unacceptable.  The professional technician will not survive very many omissions of required tasks before having to change employers or professions.  In the case above, it could mean a prison sentence.

Every job must be a masterpiece of perfection.  No gray area here folks.  It's either right or it's wrong.  Every tech who takes pride in a job well performed has the intent of doing just that.  It's that simple.  Period.


AVOIDING DISFUNCTIONAL PERFECTIONISM
 Striving for perfection can be a noble goal.  But perfectionism can be a disfunctional trait too.  Human behavior specialists know this. It can result in severe performance liabilities and degradation.  In the worst cases, it can lead to excessive compulsions that debilitate.

There has to be balance and discipline.  In the end, the job still has to end perfectly.  Any lesser goal is unaccepable.  It's an unfortunate dichotomy that the tech has to balance and be aware of;  you must progress as quickly as possible, but you must do so perfectly.  The goal must be highest so that you can "fail in style".

PAGE TWO